Monday, August 30, 2010

Ron Rash on the Daunting Challenge of Writing Short Stories

In the 35th in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize, poet, novelist and short story writer Ron Rash, author of Burning Bright (Ecco), explains why he finds the last of these the most difficult to pull off.




Because I write poems, novels, and stories, I’m sometimes asked which genre I find most challenging. My answer is the short story, because for a short story to work it must have concision akin to a poem yet also a novel’s sense of a whole life revealed. It is a daunting challenge, but when it is achieved, as in a story such as O’Connor’s “A Good Man is Hard To Find,” concision and breadth are seamlessly interwoven, and the reader is given a singular artistic experience.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Short Story Writer Thomas Lynch's Day Job Is a Serious Undertaking

This is the 34th in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize. 

It's a well known (and unfortunate)  fact that few people can make a living by writing short stories alone. Consequently, short story writers tend to have other jobs as well. Many teach. The more unusual careers of authors whose collections we've received this year include a guitar maker and a funeral home director, Thomas Lynch, author of Apparitions & Late Stories (W.W. Norton). 

Regarding the latter, in 2007, the PBS documentary series Frontline, broadcast a frank and moving documentary, "The Undertaking," about Lynch & Sons, Lynch's family owned and operated funeral home in central Michigan. The film was inspired by his nonfiction work, The Undertaking: Life Studies from the Dismal Trade. Here's the first part of that show:


Sunday, August 22, 2010

Darlin' Neal on Revisiting Her Wandering Past

In the 33rd in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize, Darlin' Neal, author of Rattlesnakes & the Moon (Press 53), discusses the influence of her rootless childhood.


What book made you want to become a writer?
It’s hard to separate out one book because my mother flooded me with wonderful books when I was a child—Jane Eyre, The Scarlet Letter, so much Dickens, but I remember very clearly reading True Grit when I was eight and how much I loved that book, how it brought the world outside alive in new ways. I started imaging the characters outside roaming the New Mexico mountains near my home. I started imagining the guys my dad worked with, and told stories about, into the book. I remember leaping up onto the bed filled with purpose and joy because I knew that’s what I wanted to do. I wanted to write books when I grew up and I wanted to run tell everyone, but I couldn’t because it was 2 o’clock in the morning and I was supposed to be sleeping. I still remember very clearly the heat of the light bulb above, how bright the room was, and my utter happiness.

What kind of research, if any, do you do?
Some of the stories in Rattlesnakes & The Moon stemmed from wondering that occurred after research into family history—“Sister Shadow,” “A Man Wrapped In Gold.” I did so much moving when I was a child, I’ve had this need to know where I came from, to make something of the separation I felt from places and people I loved. These two stories are fiction, but seeds came from that research.

This summer I spent a lot of time traveling in New Mexico to gather information about the schools I went to. There were 13 of them by the time I was 13 and it’s hard sometimes to remember when I was where, where I went from where. I’ve been writing short memoir pieces and now I plan to write a memoir.

The tug toward fictionalizing the material is strong though. During the Taos Summer Writers Conference recently, I went traveling the enchanted circle with Dorothy Allison and talking about story. My dad once paved that highway I was on. He paved just about every road in New Mexico at one time or the other. I started imagining that young guy being out there, all the way from that farm in Mississippi, looking out over those mountains and all that beauty. Roads were not only my family’s livelihood when I was a child, but truly were mostly our home, winding us from one town to another in that little trailer we lived in and could pull along.

Have you ever written a story in one sitting and not revised it?
Some stories are like gifts from the start and not much needs to be done. That doesn’t happen often. Most take many, many drafts before they let you in and start falling together. I will say that I wrote “A Man Wrapped In Gold” in one long fevered weekend, pretty much stopping only to eat with my daughter and sleep. The only thing that really changed about it since then is the frame that Rust Hills helped me with. He loved that story. His belief in my writing kept me going for a long time when part of me felt like giving up. I miss that guy being on the planet.

Have you had a mentor and who was it?
The first two writers I studied with were Kevin McIlvoy and Antonya Nelson. They were wonderful mentors and got me going down this path. I’ve been lucky the writers I’ve met and studied with. Joy Williams at the University of Arizona. Frederick Barthelme and Mary Robison at the University of Southern Mississippi. What a great loss for USM that Frederick Barthelme will no longer be teaching there and heading that magazine.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Tiphanie Yanique: "A Reader Is Always a Child"

In the 32nd in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize, Tiphanie Yanique, author of How to Escape from a Leper Colony (Graywolf Press), contemplates the divide between craft and inspiration.




It is said that a writer must be smart but not too clever; artful but not too artsy, thoughtful but not too conscious. But wouldn’t it be a wonder to see Baraka and Ashberry sit beside each other on the last train out of or into a riotous city? Is it too much a dream to consider Akhmatova sharing a piece of her people’s bread with Oliver, and Mary in turn passing Anna a lily? It is said that to write well, one must not write with political intent or social hope. But this impossibility is always what I have strived for in my own person. To be someone both artful and socially intentional.

Once upon at time craft and inspiration were good friends, lovers actually. They were ravenous lovers, co-dependent, even. Thus, were born books such as Dubliners, stories such as "Sonny’s Blues." The people all had a calling and it was called inspiration. I might also call it intention, hope, consciousness, love, hate, horniness. I mean to say that all people live inside their particular desires.

It has come to pass that some people live inside a life where they do indeed get arrested for breaking into their own castles or cabins. This might be inspiring for them to write about. Others may watch such a mess (or message, depending on if the others are participant observers or voyeurs) on TV and consider it rather fetching material for a story. Material is not the same, in this account, as inspiration. Inspiration, to be elementary, comes from inside, where the gods (or you may call them muses) reside. Material comes from without.

The time came when craft and inspiration would never again be friends. I began to see the splinter when I read stories with social awareness that were terribly written and when I began to read fiction that was skimpy on worldliness but finely crafted. The rift began when we were all children. We were told that we must be readers who value the mind or readers who value the emotion. We were taught that the very good literature took a certain mind to be appreciated, whereas the bad stuff, well, that was for babies. We did not understand this. When we read Silverstein’s The Giving Tree, we were disturbed by it, in love with. It was poetry and it was prose. We did not care. It made us want to cut down our parents. It made us want to love and never leave them. It made us want to read it again. This lasted until we were asked to pass a test, enter a contest, sell our books on shelves. Then we understood that craft and inspiration were supposed to be unfriendly toward each other. At least they should act that way. At least they should pretend.

This made all us children, who by instinct, love a good story, very sad. In his essay, “Imminence: Reflections on ‘the-about-to-be moment’ in the Comedies and Tragedies of Being Human,” Kevin McIlvoy says, “A reader is always a child, and that child is always making a wish.” The wish I had was for cool stuff to happen in what I read and wrote and for it to make me or other people feel cool and do cool stuff. Like laugh, march in the streets, curse somebody out, close the door and meditate. Those things were cool to me. But it mattered not, for the narrative went like this: The literature teachers favored stories that were obviously socially and personally aware, the creative writing teachers favored stories that were obviously crafted. And that was to be the end of it.

But it was not the end. Because people kept living lives that were socially meaningful or personally profound and they couldn’t help, if they were writers, but write about it, and they couldn’t help, if they were readers, but read about it. In my tales I have sought to write about what truly matters to me. My stories are each vastly different and are told each in a particular way via a unique voice—which must mean that my true self is schizophrenic. All those voices came out of my insides. I wanted to write about what matters and in such a way that mattered. But this must be, clearly, what matters to the child I was and still often am. It is about what inspires, you understand, me.

And so it came to pass that I wrote a story about failed nuptials that teach two families how to love. And I wrote a story about a man who catches a culturally specific disease that causes him an inconvenient paralysis. And I wrote a story about an abandoned daughter who finds relief from her pain only when having sex or dancing in a carnival parade. It was said that I cared about familial and romantic love, that I cared about colonialism and racism, that I cared about the abandonment of children and the sexual freedom of women. And it was true. But I care about them not only in my writing. I care about them first in my life. These things mattered to me as a child and they matter to the child within me and these matters are the truth and the fiction of who I am in the adult world of life and literature today. But I was not, you see, in New York when the towers fell. No one I know died. It did not, it is true, personally affect me. It might have served as material but never as inspiration. And so while I will bow my head for those dead, I will not write about them.

Ever after it will be that writers who feel they should write about war but do not really, not really, really, concern themselves much with war in their lives, are bound to write poorly. They are best off taking one of two dusty roads: writing what truly matters to them or putting aside the writing to go live inside the hopes from which they wished to be inspired. And of course the second road leads to the first and the story never ends. And we are happy for that.

Monday, August 16, 2010

David Means: Up in the Air with Joyce

In the 31st in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize, David Means, author of The Spot (Faber & Faber), reconnects with "The Dead" at 35,000 feet.


When I’m writing a first draft I try not to think too much about what the story might, in the end, be like. I go in as hard and tight as I can—writing usually by hand—and feel myself digging—as Seamus Heaney said in his great poem—with my pen. There’s a profound feeling creating a story, a sense of honing in on a missive, a single impulse—a cohesion of vision—heading toward the final page, up ahead, not too far. I’ve heard it said that characters are what count, that plot matters most, that there has to be an arc—rising action and all of that. But really, the form is much more mysterious than that and magically open to whatever it decides it needs to be, in the end, after intense revision, in order to draw the reader through a very particular experience to that final line, which then radiates out into an infinite space of the reader’s eternal imagination while, at the same time, throwing them back in a retroactive examination of what came before; that’s the beautiful thing about a great story, and the dangerous aspect—Frank O’Connor said that a story can easily end up a complete fiasco—involved.

On a flight home from Ireland a few days ago, after a quick visit to Dublin, where my wife and I stayed—accidentally—at the Gresham Hotel, the same hotel where the final scene from “The Dead” took place, I reread Joyce’s great masterpiece and felt, once again, the beautiful enigmatic sensation of that final gorgeous scene—pondering the whole thing with the actual hotel in mind, with a sense of what it might’ve been like to go up to that room on a cold, snowy night. The beautiful, sad lamentation of that moment, and the complexity of Gabriel’s relationship with his wife, the dead memory of a boy named Michael Fury, in relation to the way time moves—“He did not like to say even to himself that her face was no longer beautiful, but he knew that it was no longer the face for which Michael Furey had braved death”—could only work in relation to what had followed, earlier, in the story, to produce one single thing—again, an impulse—that, when held in my mind, threw me forward into the infinite future of my imagination and made me sit there, on the plane, in tears.

Maybe I’m being romantic, or an old fashion modernist, but on the plane I felt again the deep power of the short story form. It was a feeling that made me want to get home and to write again.

Friday, August 13, 2010

Eleven Things Jerry Gabriel Has Learned

In the 30th in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize, Jerry Gabriel, author of Drowned Boy (Sarabande Books), shares 11 points writers should keep in mind.



Here are some things I learned (or, in most cases, relearned, remembered, and/or was reminded) while writing Drowned Boy—and, frankly, since. These “lessons” are strictly for me to keep relearning, but some might find my self-talk on the subject of fiction curious.

1. Remembering about over-plotting
I always over-plot in the first draft. I blame TV and movies for this. And there may be no cure for it, because I’m doing it still, on the stories I’m working on at the moment. Perhaps it’s like knowing that you have a slice—I’m talking golf now—and aiming a little to the left. Probably it’s more like this: Drag your butt to the driving range and hit a thousand balls until your hands and back and right Achilles all ache in equal measure. Then maybe you won’t do it anymore.

2. Remember about characters
Stay focused on the characters. They’re all you have. You must let them breathe, which means tricking yourself on a daily basis, because your dumb-headed inclination is to suffocate them.

3. Remember about being clever
On a note related to No. 2, being clever will screw you every time. How some writers are able to do this successfully is not your concern.

4. Remember about not thinking
To quote my dad (and about 29 coaches I had a different points): Don’t think! React!

5. Remember about endings
Endings are the hardest part, because if the ending’s not right, then you’ve got a seriously compromised house of cards. This seems to fly in the face of the “Don’t Think! React!” dictum, but that’s a trick. Don’t fall for it.

6. Remember about getting the first line right
I only quote Frank Conroy about this one thing (though I don’t even know for sure if it was his quote or not), because I think it’s so true: The first line of a story teaches you how to read that story. Putting a story together is a lot more than thing after related thing happening; it’s echoing those first words in every line.

7. Remember about taste
There is, as they say, no accounting for taste. Indeed. And people for no reason other than this will find your work abysmal and say so, sometimes in ink, sometimes backhandedly at a party. Your job is to say: "Fair enough." Here’s the other side of this coin: People will also love your work—equally capriciously, or so it will seem—and will tell you so.

8. Remember the joy of reading fiction
Reading fiction is a joy. This weekend I was reading The Adventures of Augie March for the first time and thinking: I am so lucky! I am working right now!

9. Remember about shoddy memory
Take notes, always. Don’t say to yourself, as I said to myself just the other day: Oh, that’s a good idea. I should write it down, but then there’s no need, because I’ll definitely remember an idea that promising. This is false and pitiful logic. You will not remember it and will be haunted by this fact. Ask any cognitive scientist or judge and they will tell you what is undeniably true: Human memory sucks. This is not really even to touch on memory when you’ve had a drink or two; that probably deserves its own number.

10. Remember about “writing what you know”
When people say, "Write what you know," they mean, Write what you feel. Or possibly what you care about.

11. Remember about working
Keep your head down and work. Nobody can read about the characters dancing around in your head while you’re riding your bike or mowing the lawn. That’s because you didn’t show up for work and write the dang stories.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Adam Schuitema: How a Collection Can Be Greater Than the Sum of Its Stories

In the 29th in a series of posts on 2010 short story collections entered for The Story Prize, Adam Schuitema, author of Freshwater Boys (Delphinium Books), discusses the thinking behind the order of the stories in his collection.
Over the course of my tour in support of my book, Freshwater Boys, a number of readers have come to me with a kind of confession. They approach after the reading or raise their hands during a Q&A and admit—with a kind of wince and a shrug—that they rarely read story collections. This often leads to a discussion about what a book of stories can accomplish, and how it differs from Big Brother Novel.

I don’t mean anthologies. And I don’t mean the “collected works” or “selected stories” of a particular author. I’m speaking about a group of stories that a single writer composed and assembled within a relatively defined time period. That period may span several years, as it did with my book. But in reading that work, a person experiences a kind of time capsule, discovering the themes and images and ideas that consumed the writer while he or she created it.

While reading through Freshwater Boys again, I notice several motifs reappearing among the stories: childhood, masculinity, lives cut short, courage, ritual, and nature (particularly the landscapes around Lake Michigan). Some of these I was aware of at the time of the writing. Others came into sight after I’d arranged the individual stories and set them alongside each other.

I sometimes compare the experience of story collections to that of a painter who exhibits all of her recent works in a gallery. The individual paintings can bring satisfaction by themselves. But when they're hung alongside each other, we begin to appreciate the reappearance of certain colors and images and ideas. Each painting generates greater energy due to its proximity to the others.

To borrow an analogy from yet another art form: Many of us today download individual songs for our iPods. Yet we lose the artistry of the album: the decisions made by musicians regarding which song to begin with and which song to end with and how to organize them all so that the experience of listening—from beginning to end—brings greater satisfaction than listening to the songs individually. As short fiction writers, we can create these same dynamics through the arrangement of our stories. I’ve always admired the way other story writers, including my mentor, Stuart Dybek, crafted their books with this same thought in mind, so I tried to be just as deliberate with Freshwater Boys.

Many of the stories are “coming-of-age narratives,” and so the book begins with three stories with boys as protagonists. As the book advances, so do the ages of the protagonists. Yet even these grown men continue to grapple with the same issues that the boys do—issues they’d expected to master by this point in their lives: responsibility, maturity, fear, doubt, and loneliness. One story, “Debts and Debtors,” features a boy getting a glimpse of his father’s adult world, and because of that I arranged it within the collection where it would serve as a kind of bridge between the youthful perspectives and the more mature ones.

Arrangement is important in other ways. In some cases, two stories were placed side-by-side because they dealt with similar subject matter, so the imagery of one naturally bled into the narrative of the next. For example, “Camouflage Fall” deals with a hunting tragedy. It’s followed by a story involving four deer running through the middle of a city.

To follow up on the album analogy, I paid particular attention to how the collection would begin and how it would end. I knew that the title story, “Freshwater Boys,” would serve as the final story in the book. In its closing scene, a man is baptized in Lake Michigan. The piece is the longest and—despite its tragedies—ends with the hope and redemption that I felt was important as a closing, resonant note.

To serve as a kind of “bookend” for this, I chose “New Era, Michigan” as the opening of the collection. Like “Freshwater Boys,” it closes with a kind of sacrament—a boy burning a dead man’s artistic creations and spreading the ashes in the lake. Thus, the book’s structure (I hope) has the circular feel of the life cycles described throughout the narratives.

And who knows? Maybe a reader will notice these things. Maybe not. But with any luck—on a subconscious level, at least—these decisions will make the reading experience, ultimately, more satisfying.